Discussion:
landmark move: congress calls climate change security threat
Add Reply
M***@kymhorsell.com
2017-07-16 10:30:02 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Raw Message
<http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/07/14/in-landmark-move-gop-congress-calls-climate-change-direct-threat-to-security/>



In Landmark Move, GOP Congress Calls Climate Change `Direct Threat' to Security

Extreme weather and rising seas threaten bases from Virginia to
Guam. For the first time, a Republican House has voted to recognize
that.

Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian
July 14, 2017


Kwajalein, a tiny atoll in the Marshall Islands, is home to a
state-of-the-art radar installation called Space Fence. The
US govt awarded Lockheed Martin a nearly $1 bn contract
in 2014 to build the new system, meant to help protect US satellites
and spacecraft from space debris when it becomes operational next year.

There's just one problem. Kwajalein is a mere 10 feet above sea level,
putting Space Fence at high risk for frequent flooding as sea levels
rise over the coming decades.

It's one of many US military installations threatened by climate
change around the world. One study last year found that rising oceans
threaten 128 military installations on the coasts, including naval
facilities worth around $100 bn.

The Pentagon has been aware for years of the looming danger
represented by climate change. But partisan infighting in Congress,
budget sequestration, and the toxic nature of the climate debate have
hamstrung the Defense Dept. from taking steps to protect key assets -
or even identifying which facilities face the most serious threats.

This week, though, the Pentagon may have gotten a boost - from the
unlikeliest of places. The Republican-controlled House retained an
amendment to the 2018 defense funding bill affirming that "climate
change is a direct threat to the national security of the United
States." It orders defense officials to draw up a report laying out
which facilities would be most affected.

"This is a reflection that some Republicans at least are waking up to
this reality and voting to affirm the work that DoD is doing," said
Andrew Holland, director of studies and senior fellow for energy and
climate at the nonpartisan policy organization American Security Project.

Defense authorizations have included similar language before: In 2008,
then-Sens. John Warner (R-Va.) and Hillary Clinton (D-N.Y.) included a
similar amendment. But that was a Democratic-controlled Congress; this
time, some 45 Republicans voted for the climate-change language, and
lawmakers from both sides shot down an attempt to strike the focus on
climate change.

"I think it's maybe the beginning of a turning point in Congress," Holland said.

For more than a decade, the Pentagon has been clear-eyed about the
risks posed by climate change. Rising sea levels threaten coastal
installations, while floods, famines, and droughts promise waves of
instability and conflict across big chunks of the planet. Even in the
climate-change denying Trump administration, Defense Secretary James
Mattis has reiterated what is by now the Pentagon's standard line.

``I agree that the effects of a changing climate - such as increased
maritime access to the Arctic, rising sea levels, desertification,
among others - impact our security situation,'' Mattis expressed in
testimony prior to his confirmation.

But climate change is deeply polarizing in Congress, where many
Republicans still believe it is a "hoax," or not caused by human
activities. That makes the issue "toxic" to Pentagon staffers who need
to squeeze money out of Congress, said retired Rear Admiral David
Titley, former naval chief oceanographer and now a professor at
Pennsylvania State University. Officers tend to "run in the other
direction when anyone says climate change," afraid to appear before
Congress to argue for more resources for fear that what funding they
do have will be cut.

Years of sequestration have squeezed even the fundamentals of military
readiness. And while the Obama administration talked up the security
threats from climate change, additional funding never came.

"I don't think the Dept of Defense today could give you some
sort of ranking [of facilities] that are most under threat," said
Titley. "Especially if you consider the issues - sea level rise, water
stress, impact from wildfires - and crosscut that with the military
value of that particular base."

Rising seas, extreme weather, and water stress won't just affect
domestic military infrastructure. America's ability to project power
around the world - and particularly in the Middle East - is likely to
be weakened if no action is taken. In a 2012 report, the American
Security Project ranked the top 5 US military facilities most at
risk from climate change - Norfolk, Guam, Eglin in Florida, Bahrain,
and Diego Garcia, a shown on the map below:

The latter is the most threatened high-value base. Located on a
British atoll, the US base on Diego Garcia is a major hub for
operations in the Middle East, allowing large bombers to deploy
without being based in Saudi Arabia or Qatar and giving expeditionary
access to the Indian Ocean, Persian Gulf, and Red Sea. But due to its
location on a low-lying atoll, it's the most threatened of all.

"It legitimately could disappear in a certain amount of years," said Holland.

Closer to home, the world's biggest naval base is an even starker
illustration of what lies in store. The Hampton Roads region of
Virginia, headquarters of the Atlantic fleet, is already buffeted by
increasingly extreme weather and frequent flooding. The sea there has
already risen by more than a foot in the past 100 years, and the base
currently floods about 10 times a year. It's going to get much worse -
the Union of Concerned Scientists estimates that Norfolk may flood 280
times a year by 2100.

...


--
Zeke Hausfather @hausfath 14 Jul 2017 23:39Z
The folks at Snopes fact checked recent claims that adjustments to the data
greatly increase warming:
<https://pbs.twimg.com/card_img/885977749155741696/vwbP1esh?format=jpg&name=600x314>

Saibai islanders celebrate new seawall to fight rising ocean levels
ABC News, 15 Jul 2017 00:03Z
People on the Torres Strait's largest island of Saibai celebrate a long-
awaited seawall after more than a decade of pleading, but the future is less
certain for other sinking island communities.

Crews battle fire in St. Augustine, includes Hurricane Matthew debris ...
First Coast News, 15 Jul 2017 11:50Z

More US counties are finding Zika-carrying mosquitoes
Chicago Daily Herald, 15 Jul 2017 12:41Z

Floodwaters Hit Record Highs In River North Of Chicago
NPR, 15 Jul 2017 14:48Z

Drought in High Plains the worst some farmers have ever seen
ABC News, 15 Jul 2017 14:53Z

Peter Gleick @PeterGleick 15 Jul 2017 15:05Z
Scientists live with #climate uncertainty. It's deniers and charlatans that
walk around brazenly confident and certain in their wrongness.
1 reply 17 retweets 42 likes

Typhoon Talas to hit south China
Xinhua, 15 Jul 2017 15:51Z

Floods topple statue, trees at Fallingwater
Tribune-Review [PA], 15 Jul 2017 16:46Z

Des Plaines River rises after rains, reaches record-breaking level
Chicago Tribune, 15 Jul 2017 16:49Z

Fire Tornado Videos Go Viral After Natural Disasters in TX and California
Newsweek, 15 Jul 2017 16:50Z

Flooding in Ottawa affects businesses, floods homes
The Courier, 15 Jul 2017 20:40Z

LNP members vote down call to pull out of Paris Climate Accord
ABC News, 16 Jul 2017 06:06Z
Queensland Liberal National Party members steer away from a potentially
divisive move against Australia's global climate position, but support a
motion to ban the hijab in state schools.

Assaad Razzouk @AssaadRazzouk 16 Jul 2017 01:11Z
Sea Level Rise: Japan's Minimum Projected Rate of Beach Loss Is 18%.
Maximum? 96%. http://buff.ly/2tqhPec pic via @MotherJones #climate
<Loading Image...>
Bret Cahill
2017-07-16 14:18:33 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by M***@kymhorsell.com
<http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/07/14/in-landmark-move-gop-congress-calls-climate-change-direct-threat-to-security/>
In Landmark Move, GOP Congress Calls Climate Change `Direct Threat' to Security
Extreme weather and rising seas threaten bases from Virginia to
Guam. For the first time, a Republican House has voted to recognize
that.
Ouch! That must really hurt! Deniers getting kicked in the face by the last major denier political party on the planet!
Post by M***@kymhorsell.com
Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian
July 14, 2017
Kwajalein, a tiny atoll in the Marshall Islands, is home to a
state-of-the-art radar installation called Space Fence. The
US govt awarded Lockheed Martin a nearly $1 bn contract
in 2014 to build the new system, meant to help protect US satellites
and spacecraft from space debris when it becomes operational next year.
There's just one problem. Kwajalein is a mere 10 feet above sea level,
putting Space Fence at high risk for frequent flooding as sea levels
rise over the coming decades.
It's one of many US military installations threatened by climate
change around the world. One study last year found that rising oceans
threaten 128 military installations on the coasts, including naval
facilities worth around $100 bn.
The Pentagon has been aware for years of the looming danger
represented by climate change. But partisan infighting in Congress,
budget sequestration, and the toxic nature of the climate debate have
hamstrung the Defense Dept. from taking steps to protect key assets -
or even identifying which facilities face the most serious threats.
This week, though, the Pentagon may have gotten a boost - from the
unlikeliest of places. The Republican-controlled House retained an
amendment to the 2018 defense funding bill affirming that "climate
change is a direct threat to the national security of the United
States."
Ouch!
R Kym Horsell
2017-07-16 18:21:57 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Raw Message
Bret Cahill <***@aol.com> wrote:
...
Post by M***@kymhorsell.com
This week, though, the Pentagon may have gotten a boost - from the
unlikeliest of places. The Republican-controlled House retained an
amendment to the 2018 defense funding bill affirming that "climate
change is a direct threat to the national security of the United
States."
Ouch!
Law o da jungul 101. There's what you tells your dum supporters when you
vote to steal dere paypacket an up dere indirec taxes, but den deres what
youz dooz to pertect yor own paypackets an cut yor own taxes. Screw da WH.
--
"The state of fisheries elsewhere is improving".
-- some dipstick, Dec 2015

World:
<http://worldoceanreview.com/en/files/2013/04/wor2_c3a_s48_3-3_3-4_-
catch_volumes_world_china.jpg>

Multiple pressures on herring:
<http://worldoceanreview.com/en/files/2013/04/wor2_c3a_s61_3-
12_table_herring-500x171.jpg>
Resolute fisheries management can ensure the recovery of a fish stock. After
the North Sea herring was overfished in the 1960s (as revealed by the drop
in spawning biomass), the fishery was completely closed. The stock,
particularly the numbers of sexually mature fish (spawners), regenerated.
After renewed over-fishing in the 1990s a management plan was agreed in 1997,
which once again limited catches. The spawning stock was able to recover.
The reduction of spawning biomass since 2002 can presumably be ascribed to
climatic changes.
Bret Cahill
2017-07-16 20:28:28 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by R Kym Horsell
Post by M***@kymhorsell.com
This week, though, the Pentagon may have gotten a boost - from the
unlikeliest of places. The Republican-controlled House retained an
amendment to the 2018 defense funding bill affirming that "climate
change is a direct threat to the national security of the United
States."
Ouch!
Law o da jungul 101. There's what you tells your dum supporters when you
vote to steal dere paypacket an up dere indirec taxes, but den deres what
youz dooz to pertect yor own paypackets an cut yor own taxes. Screw da WH.
Deniers ain't postin' to this thread fer sum reason.
R Kym Horsell
2017-07-17 00:17:19 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Raw Message
Post by Bret Cahill
Post by R Kym Horsell
Post by M***@kymhorsell.com
This week, though, the Pentagon may have gotten a boost - from the
unlikeliest of places. The Republican-controlled House retained an
amendment to the 2018 defense funding bill affirming that "climate
change is a direct threat to the national security of the United
States."
Ouch!
Law o da jungul 101. There's what you tells your dum supporters when you
vote to steal dere paypacket an up dere indirec taxes, but den deres what
youz dooz to pertect yor own paypackets an cut yor own taxes. Screw da WH.
Deniers ain't postin' to this thread fer sum reason.
Wah thred? I don see no tred.
--
Av global land temperatures:

By Season:
Qtr Av temp (C)
JFM 11.9678 <-- min
AMJ 12.0434
JAS 12.1164 <-- max range = 0.1486
OND 12.1000

By Decade:
Year deg C rel to mly avg for each grid
1850 0.0769
1860 0.0507
1870 0.0541
1880 -0.1550
1890 -0.1992
1900 -0.2320
1910 -0.2851 <-- min
1920 -0.0830
1930 0.2694
1940 0.0849
1950 0.0544
1960 -0.0857
1970 -0.0789
1980 0.0986
1990 0.6032 <-- max range = 0.8883
trend = 0.00568312 +- 0.00513942 C/yr 90 %CI

So GW 1850-2000 has warmed on average 5x more than the
difference between summer and winter, aka "5 summers worth".
IOW 2000 winter == 1850 summer and then some.
Loading...